# TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies - TDSB

←

**Page content transcription**

If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below

TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies Research & Information Services Toronto District School Board November 2016 Report No. 16/17-08

TITLE: Teaching and Learning Mathematics Research Series l: Effective Instructional Strategies AUTHORS: Erhan Sinay and Ashley Nahornick Copyright © Toronto District School Board (November 2016) Cite as: Sinay, E., & Nahornick, A. (2016). Teaching and learning mathematics research series l: Effective instructional strategies. (Research Report No. 16/17-08). Toronto, Ontario, Canada: Toronto District School Board. Reproduction of this document for use in the schools of the Toronto District School Board is encouraged. For any other purpose, permission must be requested and obtained in writing from: Research & Information Services Toronto District School Board 1 Civic Centre Court, Lower Level Etobicoke, ON M9C 2B3 Fax: 416-394-4946 Every reasonable precaution has been taken to trace the owners of copyrighted material and to make due acknowledgement. Any omission will gladly be rectified in future printings. R02(Renewed Mathematics Strategy\Research\Series l\Teaching and Learning Math Research Series 1)es.1485

TABLE OF CONTENTS BACKGROUND AND RATIONALE ...........................................................................................3 Create a Supportive and Engaging Classroom Environment .....................................3 Provide Strong Mathematics Foundations in the Early Years ...................................4 Importance of Early Years’ Mathematics...................................................................5 Create Appropriate Curriculum Standards ................................................................5 Develop Knowledge of Children’s Developmental Process .......................................5 Implement Appropriate Classroom Activities............................................................6 Teach Mathematics in an Interdisciplinary Manner ..................................................6 Maintain Positive Attitudes about Mathematics .......................................................6 Be Knowledgeable about Mathematics .....................................................................7 Early Years Strategies and Programs from Other Jurisdictions .................................7 Australia .........................................................................................................7 Prince Edward Island – Canada ......................................................................7 United Kingdom .............................................................................................7 EFFECTIVE TEACHING STRATEGIES FOR ALL GRADES ...................................................... 9 Teach for Conceptual Understanding ........................................................................9 Teach Reasoning Skills ...............................................................................................10 Promote Problem-solving ..........................................................................................11 Creativity in Mathematics ..........................................................................................12 Encourage and Support Collaboration in Mathematics ............................................13 Provide an Inquiry Environment ................................................................................14 Use Three-Part Mathematics Lesson Plans ...............................................................15 Teaching and Learning with Technology ...................................................................15 Develop Mental Mathematics Skills ..........................................................................18 Have High Expectations .............................................................................................19 Assign Meaningful Homework ...................................................................................20 Make Mathematics Fun .............................................................................................21 Building Positive Attitudes in Mathematics ...............................................................22 Reduce Mathematics Anxiety ....................................................................................23 Provide Varied and Ongoing Assessment ..................................................................24 Give Meaning to Mathematics through Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics ..............................................................................................................24 Support Conceptual Thinking.....................................................................................25 Use Manipulatives with Minimal Visual Distractions ................................................26 How to Implement Successful System Wide Interventions .......................................27 SUMMARY AND RECOMMENDATIONS .......................................................................... 29 REFERENCES ................................................................................................................. 33 i

TABLES Table 1: Summary of Recommendations for Teaching and Learning Mathematics .................................................................................29 FIGURES Figure 1: Recommendations for Creating a Supportive and Engaging Classroom ....................................................................................4 Figure 2: Provide a Strong Early Years mathematics Foundation .............................8 Figure 3: Teach for Conceptual Understanding .........................................................10 Figure 4: Teach Reasoning Skills ................................................................................10 Figure 5: Promote Problem-solving ...........................................................................12 Figure 6: Creativity in Mathematics ...........................................................................13 Figure 7: Encourage and Support Collaboration in Mathematics .............................14 Figure 8: Provide an Inquiry-based Environment ......................................................14 Figure 9: Three-Part Mathematics Lesson Plans .......................................................15 Figure 10: Teaching and Learning with Technology ..................................................17 Figure 11: Mental Mathematics Skills........................................................................18 Figure 12: Importance of Having High Expectations .................................................19 Figure 13: Assign Meaningful Homework ..................................................................20 Figure 14: Making Mathematics Fun .........................................................................21 Figure 15: Building Positive Attitudes in Mathematics ..............................................22 Figure 16: Recommendations to Reduce Mathematics Anxiety ...............................23 Figure 17: Mathematics Assessments .......................................................................24 Figure 18: Give Meaning to Mathematics through STEM .........................................25 Figure 19: Computational Thinking............................................................................26 Figure 20: Information on Manipulatives ..................................................................26 Figure 21: Response to Interventions ........................................................................27 Figure 22: Summary of Key Recommendations.........................................................32 ii

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We would like to thank and acknowledge the support and contributions of the following reviewers in this study: Thomas G. Ryan, Professor, Faculty of Education, Nipissing University Kamini Jaipal-Jamani, Associate Professor, Department of Teacher Education Brock University, Faculty of Education Margaret Douglin, Research Coordinator, Research & Information Services, Toronto District School Board TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 1

2 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

BACKGROUND AND RATIONALE Mathematics is foundational in many ways that informs our decisions in areas of our lives. Teaching and learning mathematics is at the heart of education. Learning mathematics aims to link school to everyday life, provide skill acquisition, prepare students for the workforce, and foster mathematical thinking (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2005). Mathematics involves learning to problem-solve, investigate, represent, and communicate mathematical concepts and ideas, and making connections to everyday life (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2005). However, there is a concern that Canadian students’ mathematical achievements are on the decline (EQAO, 2012). In 2012, the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), an international study examining 15-year-old students’ mathematical performance among 60 countries or economies, showed that math scores in Ontario have declined by 16 percentage points over the last nine years (EQAO, 2012). Historical results of Education Quality and Accountability Office (EQAO) assessments also showed considerable decline in mathematics achievement overtime. Over the past five years (2011-12 to 2015-16), Ontario’s Grade 3 students’ results declined by five percentage points, from 68% to 63% and Grade 6 students’ results declined by eight percentage points from 58% to 50%. The province had the lowest improvement in Grade 6 mathematics compared to any of the other EQAO assessments since 1998-99 (4 percentage points from 46% to 50%). For all of the other assessments, there were 10 to 34 percentage point improvements since the test was administered in 1997-981. Additionally, the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) conducted in 2011, which examined mathematics and science achievements for students in Grades 4 and 8, demonstrated that only 33% of students in Grade 4 and 32% of students in Grade 8 indicated high levels of confidence in math (EQAO, 2011). Mathematical skills and confidence are essential for students. Given the importance of mathematical skills and confidence, this study focuses on research-based instructional strategies that can provide guidance for effective classroom practices for supporting student development in mathematics. Create a Supportive and Engaging Classroom Environment A supportive and engaging classroom environment is important to help develop students’ mathematical understanding and confidence (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2005). The classroom needs to be a place of investigation, where students do meaningful mathematics in a safe and positive space. “Meaningful mathematics takes place in K to 12 classrooms that support students as they investigate, represent and connect mathematical ideas through discussion in the context of problem solving” (Suurtamm et al., 2015). 1 These results were gathered from historical reports provided by EQAO. EQAO Grade 3 assessments started in 1996-97, Grade 6 in 1998-99, Grade 9 Assessment of Mathematics in 2000-01; and the first Ontario Secondary School Literacy Test (OSSLT) was administered as a pilot in 2000-01. TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 3

The classroom needs to be made a place of investigation by supporting unusual ideas and responses by students (Feldhusen & Treffinger, 1985; Nickerson, 1999; Sternberg & Williams, 1996). Bruce (2007), who studied ways to improve students’ educational experience in mathematics, explains that discussion in the mathematics classroom is very important. The mathematics classroom should feel like a community where ideas can be discussed, developed, debated, and understood (Bruce, 2007). Students should feel that all ideas are welcome in the classroom, even those that are unconventional (Nickerson, 1999). One way to encourage classroom dialogue in mathematics is through “Math Talk.” Math Talk is a way to have structured mathematical discussions that construct knowledge and meaning (Hufferd-Ackles, Fuson, & Gamoran Sherin, 2004). Students become the co-constructors of knowledge through asking questions, justifying their work, and communicating their ideas to each other (Wagganer, 2015). Students are asked to explain their ideas, justify their thinking, and question one another on their work and compare and contrast ideas and solutions (Suurtamm et al., 2015). Teachers guide and extend students’ learning through mathematics discussion questions, sentence stems (sometimes called sentence starters), asking for examples, and asking for justifications of work (Wagganer, 2015). Bruce (2007) suggests giving students sufficient time to do math talk, and not to intervene with probing questions or ideas too quickly. Additionally, Bruce (2007) suggests math talk could be part of the classroom assessment. Recommendations for a Supportive and Engaging Figure 1: Recommendations for Creating a Supportive and Engaging Classroom Classroom Make the classroom a place of investigation (Suurtamm et al., 2015) Students should feel all ideas are welcome in the classroom (Nickerson, 1999) Encourage mathematics discussion through “Math Talk” (Hufferd-Ackles et al., 2004) Provide Strong Mathematics Foundations in the Early Years More and more jurisdictions, teacher associations, and researchers (Duncan et al., 2007; Ontario Ministry of Education, 2003; National Association for the Education of Young Children [NAEYC] & National Association of Early Childhood Specialists in State Departments of Education (NAECS/SDE 2003; National Research Council, 2009; Student Achievement Division, 2011) continue to advocate for providing our very young children with a strong mathematics foundation. Providing our youngest learners with a strong mathematics foundation can play an important role in future academic achievement. Researchers have found that early years’ math 4 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

skills can have a strong predictive power for future academic achievement (Duncan et al., 2007). Furthermore, the Canadian Child Care Federation (2010) has found that most differences in children’s numeracy skills in school can be linked to the opportunities children had at home and early childhood environments. As such, the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics [NCTM] (2013) strongly advocates for greater access to pre-kindergarten programs for all students. Importance of Early Years’ Mathematics Young children, even infants, need to be stimulated and challenged mathematically. “Claims that children are either too young, in the wrong stage or not ready to learning something have been shown time and time and again to be wrong” (National Mathematics Advisory Panel [NMPA], 2008, p.13). Young children need to be stimulated at home and/or through early childhood education environments by thinking and talking about numbers, discussing mathematics around them, looking for patterns, and classifying similarities and differences of objects (Berger, n.d). There is no age too early to learn math. It has been shown that children as young as infants can tell differences between small quantities, and that even before kindergarten, children are able to look for patterns and discuss similarities and differences in quantity (Canadian Child Care Federation, 2010). Create Appropriate Curriculum Standards Research supports creating standards based on early childhood mathematics education (NAEYC & NAECS/SDE, 2003; National Research Council, 2009; National Council of Teachers of Mathematics [NCTM], 2013). This includes creating curriculum standards, resources, and challenging mathematics activities directed to young learners. The NCTM (2013) advocates that “young children in every setting should experience mathematics through effective, research- based curricula and teaching practices” (p. 1). The NCTM (2013) recommends that early years’ mathematics education should focus on four big ideas: (1) numbers and operations, (2) geometry, (3) algebraic reasoning, and (4) measurement. The Ontario Ministry of Education Early Math Strategy recommends having students focus on patterns, shapes, comparisons, number sense, and problem-solving (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2003). Nonetheless, the overarching goal is to ensure our youngest learners are receiving challenging and stimulating mathematics learning environments. Balfanz (1999) contends that often the curriculum for early years is insufficient since young students bring more mathematical knowledge to school than we think. Develop Knowledge of Children’s Developmental Process It is important for educators to be mindful of the developmental process and unique characteristics of young learners (Student Achievement Division, 2011). Young learners go through different stages of development as they grow and as a result, early years practitioners need to have a strong understanding of the development and characteristics of young learners (Student Achievement Division, 2011). For example, from ages 3-6, children learn to formalize TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 5

their thinking by using their knowledge, experiences, and vocabulary to mathematize their ideas (Berger, n.d). Since young children do not see things in the same way as adults, early childhood educators need to understand the child’s point of view, and not impose their thinking (Student Achievement Division, 2011). Implement Appropriate Classroom Activities Young learners are curious and playful when it comes to mathematics, and learn by doing, thinking, and talking (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2003). They do not memorize mathematics. Early childhood learning should focus on capitalizing on this inquisitive behavior by encouraging curiosity and investigations (Berger, n.d). Free play should be encouraged in early years’ mathematics education by focusing to maximize students’ mathematical learning, for example asking students probing questions during play time to promote student thinking. Additionally, students should do more than play (Berger, n.d). They should be pushed to discuss mathematics, use appropriate mathematics vocabulary and extend their learning (Berger, n.d). Early years’ educators should encourage “Math Talk” to foster mathematical dialogue (Student Achievement Division, 2011). Other instructional recommendations include: (1) using problems that have meaning for young learners, not problems that hold meaning to you as an adult, (2) allowing for creativity, (3) encouraging and supporting different problem-solving methods, (4) scaffolding, and (5) helping with creating connections (Student Achievement Division, 2011). Teach Mathematics in an Interdisciplinary Manner It is recommended that early years educators teach mathematics in an interdisciplinary manner, connecting mathematics to other subjects (NCTM, 2013). The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (1995) argues that K-4 teaching should be interdisciplinary in nature and be organized by questions, burning issues, problems or projects that connect mathematics, science and reading. Nikitina and Mansilla (2003) explain that mathematics is often taught in isolation from other subject areas, creating a lack of motivation for students to learn mathematics. The NCTM (1995) recommends teaching mathematics concepts as part of interdisciplinary units to foster student interest, create authentic connections, and real-life connections. Maintain Positive Attitudes about Mathematics Another important component of quality math instruction for the early years is to inculcate in learners a positive attitude about mathematics. The Ontario Ministry of Education (2003) maintains that “a positive attitude towards mathematics, an understanding of key concepts, and mathematical skills must be developed in the early grades” (p.1). Students can be very much affected by the attitudes and beliefs of their teachers. Teachers should promote positive attitudes and actions about mathematics (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2003). 6 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

Be Knowledgeable about Mathematics Early childhood educators need to be knowledgeable about mathematics (Student Achievement Division, 2011). As teachers we must be able to explain what we are doing and why in mathematics. Ball (2008) explains that teacher content knowledge can play an important role in student achievement. Teachers need to know mathematics content, underlying reasons behind the mathematics and curriculum expectations (Student Achievement Division, 2011). NCTM (2013) suggests that early childhood educators attend professional development on mathematics content and teaching of math. Early Years Strategies and Programs from Other Jurisdictions Early years education sets the stage for learning, and as such, many jurisdictions are creating strategies, programs, and interventions to improve numeracy skills among early years’ students. Following are descriptions of some intervention programs by jurisdiction, along with links for additional information. Australia Meiers, Reid, McKenzie, and Mellor (2013) prepared a detailed evidence-based report on literacy and numeracy interventions in the early years (K-3) for the Ministerial Advisory Group on Literacy and Numeracy. The report includes discussion of interventions used in Australian schools, focusing on instructional practices in math, early intervention protocols, professional learning, effective assessment, and developing teachers’ understanding of how children learn math. The report includes numerous ideas for numeracy interventions and easy to understand information on the target population, appropriate grade level, intervention focus, and evidence from studies across Australia. For more information, go to: http://research.acer.edu.au/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1019&context=policy_analysis_misc Dooley, Dunphy, and Shiel (2014) produced a detailed research report for the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (ages 3-8) in Australia. Their report discusses mathematics pedagogy for the early years, recommended teacher practices, curriculum recommendations, effective teacher preparation and creating partnership with parents. For more information, go to: http://ncca.ie/en/Publications/Reports/NCCA_Research_Report_18.pdf Prince Edward Island - Canada The Prince Edward Island Department of Education (2012) published a report on their province- wide early intervention program in numeracy. The report details a pilot study for numeracy intervention with at-risk students in Grades 1-3 using mathematics consultants. For more information, go to: http://www.gov.pe.ca/photos/original/eecd_ENIP201011.pdf United Kingdom The United Kingdom Department of Education (2012) has put forth a document outlining numeracy catch-up strategies for underperforming students. The report goes into detail about each of the recommended strategies. The document discusses numeracy interventions, TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 7

classroom practice strategies, and pedagogy and approaches to support low achieving students. For more information, go to: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/268031/liter acy_and_numeracy_catch_up_strategies_in_secondary_schools.pdf Giford (2014) authored an article for the Advisory Committee on Mathematics Education effective and appropriate early years mathematics pedagogy, and ways to improve success in mathematics. For this article, go to: https://nrich.maths.org/11441 Figure 2: Provide a Strong Early Years Mathematics Foundation Provide a Strong Early Years’ Mathematics Foundation 01 Why is it important? 04 What should teachers do? • Maintain a positive Many jurisdictions are Differences in numeracy attitude about creating interventions skills can be linked to mathematics (Ministry of programs to improve opportunities early Education Ontario, 2003) numeracy skills among childhood environments • Teach math in an early years’ students. (Canadian Child Care Federation, 2010) interdisciplinary manner (NCTM, 2013) See more details about • Ask probing questions programs in Australia, during free play Prince Edward Island 02 What needs to be done? (Canada), and the United Kingdom All children should have access to an evidence 03 How does this affect teaching? based standards pre- Teachers need to have a kindergarten program strong understanding of: (NCTM, 2013) (1) children’s development process and (2) a strong 05 What are other jurisdictions doing? knowledge of mathematics (Student Achievement Division, 2011) 8 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

EFFECTIVE TEACHING STRATEGIES FOR ALL GRADES Teach for Conceptual Understanding There is growing evidence that students develop procedural fluency in mathematics, but have difficulty with conceptual understanding (Lawson, 2007). Procedural fluency is the ability to apply and use steps or strategies for different problems (NCTM, n.d), while conceptual understanding is the knowledge of abstract ideas (Rittle-Johnson & Schneider, 2014). Researchers stress the importance of teaching for conceptual understanding (Lawson, 2007; Protheroe, 2007). However, mathematics classes often focus on drills and procedural understanding (Protheroe, 2007), even though “the curriculum is designed to help students build the solid conceptual foundation in mathematics that will enable them to apply their knowledge and further their learning successfully” (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2005 p. 4). Memorizing mathematics is not sufficient for developing understanding. Students need to be taught to understand the concepts behind procedures (NCTM, n.d). Hiebert (1999) explains that once students learn a procedure, they often have little motivation to learn the underlying concepts behind the procedures. As such, the NCTM (n.d) recommends that students learn the concepts behind the procedures either before or during the instruction of procedures, not after. Some additional recommended teaching practices for teaching conceptual understanding include: Students should be asked to connect procedures to underlying concepts o For example, when students are learning about division, explain why they cannot divide by zero (Wathall, 2016) Students should be asked to justify their processes (NCTM, n.d) and give self- explanation (Rittle-Johnson & Schnieder, 2014) Students should be pushed to work on interesting problems that allow for student generated solutions (Lawson, 2016), facilitate multiple representations, and promote student interaction (Suurtamm et al., 2015). Students should compare alternate solution methods (Rittle-Johnson & Schnieder, 2014) Students should compare incorrect procedures (Rittle-Johnson & Schnieder, 2014) Students need time to work on unfamiliar problems prior to instruction (Rittle-Johnson & Schnieder, 2014) TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 9

Teach for Conceptual Understanding Figure 3: Teach for Conceptual Understanding Student often have difficulty with conceptual Conceptual understanding is understanding (Lawson, the knowledge of abstract 2007) 01 ideas (Rittle-Johnson and Schneider, 2014) 03 02 Teach students the concepts Students should be asked to behind procedures before or justify their processes (NCTM, during instruction of procedures (NCTM,n.d) 04 n.d), facilitate different solution methods ( Suurtamm et al,, 2015) and work on unfamiliar problems (Rittle-Johnson and Schnieder, 2014) Teach Reasoning Skills Research suggests that improving students’ reasoning may improve their mathematical abilities (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan, 2016). Reasoning skills include such things as identifying similarities and differences, size, or shape. Kidd, Carlson, Gadzichowski, Boyer, Gallington, and Pasnak (2013) studied students in Grade 1 who had low patterning skills and who were randomly selected for instruction on learning about patterns or numeracy, and found that students who had instruction on patterns outperformed students who received general numeracy instruction. Overall, directly teaching reasoning skills in mathematics may help develop students’ mathematical abilities. Figure 4: Teach Reasoning Skills This may help develop students mathematical This includes: abilities (Rittle- identifying Johnson & similarities and Jordan, 2016) differences, size Teach reasoning or shape skills 10 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

Promote Problem-solving Problem-solving is a foundational building block for learning mathematics. “By learning to solve problems and by learning through problem-solving, students are given numerous opportunities to connect mathematical ideas and to develop conceptual understanding” (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2005, p. 11). When the term problem-solving is used, it means that a solver is working on a question where the solver does not know a direct path to achieve the goal (Polya, 1945). Problem-solving is all about coming up with original thoughts, not about practicing drills or algorithms (Polya, 1945). According to Beigie (2008) “a mathematical question may be sophisticated, but it is not a problem unless the student makes real decisions on how to construct the solution” (p. 353). As such, a problem exists when the method of solving is unknown and a solution is necessary (Dossey, McCrone, & O’Sullivan, 2006). Students need ongoing and continuous opportunities to work on interesting and rich mathematical problems. Many studies suggest that questions labelled as problems in school disregard reality, are rigid, and focus too heavily on procedural fluency. A study of international research on problem-solving found that students often disregard reality when solving problems because the questions are just a way to practice a procedure or algorithm (Greer, 1997). According to Suurtamm et al. (2015) who examined ways to make space for students to think mathematically, it is important to present problems in the mathematics classroom that are complex and rich, allowing for multiple entry points, different approaches, scaffolding, and engagement without imposed procedural steps. Several researchers (Barwell, 2011; Hoffman & Brahier, 2008; Suurtamm et al., 2015) suggest having students solve open-ended problems. Open-ended problems are questions that allow for a variety of problem-solving methods and a variety of answers. According to Suurtamm et al. (2015), open-ended problems allow students to critically think and improve sense-making because they are forced to work with unfamiliar situations without a guided solution method and procedure to follow. Other research-based recommendations related to problem-solving include allowing students to create and solve their own problems (Barwell, 2011), work on problems mirroring authentic real-life scenarios (Archbald & Newmann, 1988), compare multiple ways to solve problems (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan, 2016), critique common mistakes (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan, 2016), and mathematize the world around them (Barwell, 2011). TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 11

Figure 5: Promote Problem-solving Step Promote Present complex and rich 01 Problem- solving problems that allow for original thought Such as problems: with multiple entry Step points (Suurtamm et al, 2015), are Present open-ended (Barwell, 2011), that are 02 various types of problems student created to mathematize the world around them.(Barwell, 2011) Step Make problem-solving an Allow for ongoing and continuous 03 many opportunities part of your classroom Creativity in Mathematics Thinking creatively is at the heart of mathematics (Guilford, 1959); however, most students have little opportunity to experience creativity in mathematics (Silver, 1997). Creative thinking can be developed my making the classroom a place of investigation. Quite often mathematics instruction focuses on drills and algorithms. As such, students often think that mathematics is black and white, with right and wrong answers, and questions that can be solved in 1-2 steps. Whitcombe (1988) explains that classroom environments perpetuate these ideas by focusing only on practical applications of mathematics, presenting boring material and having a rushed learning schedule. Mathematics teaching should focus on mathematical thinking and creativity. Hoffman and Brahier (2008) discuss these ideas in light of past TIMSS results and suggest having students work on rich and complex problems, such as open-ended problems that allow students to make conjectures, ask sub-problems, critically analyze situations, and work with unfamiliar situations. Creativity takes time and experience to develop (Pehkonen, 1997). Students should be given ample time to grapple with stimulating problems (Burns, 1992). Mathematics is not what is seen in textbooks; mathematics is much more than drill-like activities, and students need to be given time and multiple opportunities to work on problems that require them to be resourceful and creative (Pehkonen, 1997). 12 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

Figure 6: Creativity in Mathematics Creativity in Math 01 03 Have students work on rich problems, Most students have little opportunity to be creative in 02 allow students to make conjectures, math (Silver, 1997) Focus on creativity in the ask sub-problems and classroom. Give student ample time analyze problems. and opportunities to be creative. Encourage and Support Collaboration in Mathematics Mathematics collaboration needs to be encouraged and supported in the classroom. Collaboration is an important way to foster mathematical understanding and increased confidence in mathematics (MacMath, Wallace, & Xiaohong, 2009). By providing a classroom environment where students feel comfortable to collaborate, share, explore, and think mathematically, mathematical confidence can improve (Suurtamm et al., 2015). Substantial research exists explaining that collaboration improves self-confidence (Evans & Dion, 1991), feelings of unity (Evans & Dion, 1991), improved satisfaction (Tett & Meyer, 1993), and cohesiveness (Evans & Dion, 1991). Collaborative work can lead to increased commitment and increased feelings of unity. Lewin (1943), the pioneer of group dynamics, explains that when people have a common goal, it is more likely to be achieved. During World War II, Lewin researched this phenomenon, by testing whether people were more likely to eat undesirable food when they were in a group, and indeed they were (Lewin, 1943). Similarly, promoting collaboration in the mathematics classroom may lead to increased commitment and unity (Suurtamm et al., 2015). Another benefit of collaboration is its effect on problem-solving. Small group brainstorming during the problem-solving process can have positive effects on later stages of the problem- solving process. Additionally, groups who brainstormed together benefitted during the later steps of the problem-solving process due to increased coordination and cohesion when problem-solving (Fleming, 2000). Collaboration can also help with creating strong personal relationships. In the classroom environment, Hasler-Waters, and Napier (2002) suggest that collaboration allows students to leverage the strength of their classmates, build relationships, and learn teamwork. An innovative approach recommended by the Institute of Education Services at the U.S. TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 13

Department of Education suggests using technology to support students’ collaboration (Rittle- Johnson & Jordan, 2016). This could include computer-based group problem-solving, online Reasons discussion boards, to andEncourage andprograms. online mathematics Support Collaboration in Math Figure 7: Encourage and Support Collaboration in Mathematics 01 02 03 Collaboration Collaboration Collaboration can improve can to lead to can lead to students strong improved self- personal problem- confidence ( relationships solving Evans & (Hasler- abilities ( Dion, 1991) Waters & Fleming, Napier, 2000). 2002) Provide an Inquiry Environment Many educators and researchers advocate for an inquiry-based learning environment (Suurtamm et al., 2015). An inquiry-based learning environment occurs when students take an active role in learning, and the teacher’s role becomes more of a curator of the learning. Inquiry is a way for students to discover mathematics, making mathematics more than just skills and procedures (PRIMAS, 2011). In other words, inquiry-based learning “is a way of teaching and learning mathematics and science in which students are invited to work in the way mathematicians and scientists work” (PRIMAS, 2011, p. 10).2 Figure 8: Provide an Inquiry-based Environment Provide an inquiry-based environment An inquiry-based learning environment has students take an active role in the learning, and is advocated by many educators. 2 To learn more about inquiry-based learning, the Student Achievement Division in Ontario has published a Capacity Building Series on Inquiry- based learning which can be found at the following link: http://www.edu.gov.on.ca/eng/literacynumeracy/inspire/research/CBS_InquiryBased.pdf 14 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

Use Three-Part Mathematics Lesson Plans Three-part mathematics lessons are a lesson planning method focused on inquiry-based learning supported by the Ontario College of Teachers and National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (Foote, Earnest, Mukhopadhyay, & Curcio, 2014; Ontario College of Teachers, n.d). The three-part math lesson planning technique is supported by the NCTM as an effective way to teach mathematics curriculum standards, support differentiated learning, create an inclusive classroom, promote problem-solving, and engage students in mathematics (Foote et al., 2014). The idea of three-part lessons is to have a hands-on learning experience where the focus is on problem-solving and critical thinking, rather than memorization (Foote et al., 2014). The structure of the three-part lesson includes three components: The first component: “Launching the Task”, focuses on getting students excited and cognitively prepared for the lesson. Thereafter, “Task Exploration” is where students explore a mathematics expectation that gives them an opportunity to think, explore, and ask question (Foote et al., 2014). During the “Task Exploration” stages, students often work in small groups while the teacher circulates (Foote et al., 2014). The third stage is “Summarizing Discussion” where the students reflect, discuss, and critically think about their learning. This is the stage where students make connections and link ideas (Foote et al., 2014). Figure 9: Three-Part Mathematics Lesson Plans Teaching and Learning with Technology Teaching and learning with technology is an important part of the mathematics classroom. According to the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (2011a), “it is essential that teachers and students have regular access to technologies that support and advance mathematical sense making, reasoning, problem solving, and communication” (p. 1). Several studies (Gadanidis & Geiger, 2010; Kastberg & Leatham, 2005) have demonstrated that utilizing TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 15

technology when teaching mathematics can support students in procedural skills, problem- solving, and reasoning. In a meta-analysis of research on the impact of technology on learning, it was found that students who used technology in their classroom perform 12 percentage points higher than those who do not (Tamin, Bernard, Borokhovski, Abrami, & Schmidt, 2011). Different examples of technology in mathematics include: online assessment tools, online collaboration tools, computer algebra systems, apps, calculators, computer applications, and interactive whiteboards (Tamin et al., 2011). Online assessments are one technology tool that can be useful in teaching and learning mathematics (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan, 2016). Online assessments are a way to help identify student strengths and weaknesses, misconceptions in understanding, and test for knowledge (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan, 2016). An important benefit of online assessments is that they are self-paced and that they give the student immediate feedback (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan, 2016). Konstantopoulous, Miller, and van der Ploeg (2013) studied the use of interim computer assessments with students in Grades K-8 in the state of Indiana and found that students in Grades 3-8 who worked on interim computer assessments achieved higher scores on state exams. Rittle-Johnson and Jordan (2016) examined studies on interim computer assessments and found that assessments that focus on misconceptions and accuracy are a good way to help with learning mathematics. Online collaboration tools are yet another technology tool that can aid in the teaching and learning of mathematics. Research on instructional practices for mathematics achievement found that there is a correlation between mathematics achievement and collaboration in the mathematics classroom (Bottia, Moller, Michelson, & Stearns, 2014). One such online collaboration tool was created by The Institute of Education Science called TechPALS, where students work on mathematics problems collaboratively using devices (Roshcelle et al., 2010). Roshcelle et al. (2010) completed a study with students in Grade 4 using TechPALS and while the findings were not extensive, the results demonstrated that students who used TechPALS showed a greater knowledge of fractions and were more likely to ask questions. Calculators are another technology tool that can be used purposefully in math to help with achievement. The Ontario Mathematics Curriculum for students in Grades 1-8 supports the use of calculators and explicitly states “the computer and the calculator should be seen as important problem-solving tools to be used for many purposes” (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2005, p. 15). The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (2015) echoes this sentiment with their position statement that calculators should be used strategically to help with reasoning and problem-solving. Katsberg and Leatham (2005) conducted research on graphing calculators in secondary school mathematics and found that access to and use of graphing calculators can improve achievement and facilitate understanding. Harskamp, Suhre, and Van Streun (1998) conducted a study with twelve Grade 12 classes and found that students with access to graphing calculators had a better repertoire of problem-solving strategies than those who did not. Nonetheless, NCTM (2015) makes it a point to remind educators that calculators 16 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

do not negate the need for students to develop proficiency in mental and paper and pencil calculations, and should be used strategically to support learning. Interactive white boards are yet another example of technology that can be used strategically in the mathematics classroom. Using interactive white boards in mathematics as dynamic and non-dynamic presentation tools have been shown to increase student engagement and improve whole-class discussion (Bruce, 2012). Interactive whiteboards allow for a variety of representations, student interaction, and visually stimulating graphics (Bruce, 2012). However, interactive white boards are not a magic bullet for student understanding, as teachers must still focus on teaching strategies, pedagogy, and assessments to make the class effective. Figure 10: Teaching and Learning with Technology 01 It is essential that teachers and 02 students have technology in math to Use interactive whiteboards to support learning (NCTM, 2011) increase students engagements and ignite discussion (Bruce, 2012). Use online assessments and online Use calculators strategically to collaboration tools to aid in student help with reasoning and problem- learning (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan,2016) solving (NCTM, 2011a). 03 04 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 17

Develop Mental Mathematics Skills Mental math skills are important and are often used in commerce, work, and everyday activities, yet many students are calculator dependent. Mental math strategies are different than paper and pencil strategies and need to be cultivated (Victoria State Government, 2009). The Victoria State Government in Australia (2009) argues that students should be taught mental math strategies and develop these strategies at school throughout the grades. Recommendations to develop mental math skills include: Teaching mental math skills (Victoria State Government, 2009) Providing class time to practice (Rubenstein, 2001) o Spending 10-15 minutes a few times a week working on mental math o Focusing on approaches, not speed (McInstosh, 2005; McIntosh, de Nardi & Swan, 1994) Discussing different strategies used (McInstosh, 2005; McIntosh, de Nardi & Swan, 1994) Using examples in students’ daily life where mental math is used and have them explain different ways to approach the calculations (Rubenstein, 2001). Mental Math Skills Figure 11: Mental Mathematics Skills Mental math skills are different than paper and pencil strategies ( Victoria 01 State Government, 2009) Teach mental math skills explicitly (Rubenstein, 2001) 02 Given ample class time to practice throughout the grades (Rubenstein, 03 2001) Focus on approaches, not speed (McInstosh, 2005; McIntosh, de Nardi & 04 Swan, 1994) Have students discuss different ways to approach calculations (Rubenstein, 2001) 05 18 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

Have High Expectations Having high expectations of students in mathematics is at the core of good teaching (Jamar & Pitts, 2005). Having high expectations means believing all students can learn, be challenged, and push themselves as far as they can go (NCTM, 2011b). The NCTM (2011b) explains that holding high expectations is a fundamental tenet of equity since providing challenging and stimulating courses and mathematics environments should be a basic right for all students. As such, the Ontario Mathematics Curriculum Grades 1-8, maintains that “teachers should have high expectations for all students” (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2005, p. 29). Jamar and Pitts (2005) studied the effect of teacher expectations with African-American students and found that teachers who had low expectations for students can lead to lower achievement results. Barshay (2016) reports a study by the OECD found that teachers who taught students from a low socio-economic background provided less rigorous mathematics learning to their students than those teachers who taught high socio-economic students. As such, NCTM (2011b) recommends that all students should be challenged, and suggests students should be given challenging tasks throughout units of learning, not just at the end of a unit. Importance of Having High Expectations Figure 12: Importance of Having High Expectations Educators need to Having high expectations Having lower challenge all students, for all students is a basic expectations can lead and give challenging tenant of education to lower achievement tasks throughout units, (NCTM, 2011b) results ( Pitts, 2005) not just at the end (NCTM, 2011b) TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 19

Assign Meaningful Homework In many mathematics classrooms, homework is assigned on a regular basis, but what does the research say about homework? According to the NCTM (n.d.), homework can improve academic achievement, but the homework needs to be meaningful and purposeful. Swank (1999) studied whether drill based homework assignments improve achievement in math, and found no significant difference between students who completed the homework assignments and those who did not. As such, Swank (1999) argues that homework assignments should not be drill and practice tasks. Another important factor with homework is how to effectively take up homework. Otten, Cirillo, and Herbel-Eisenmann (2015) explain that often a large portion of class time is taken up with going over homework, one problem at a time, talking about correct answers or explanations. Otten et al., (2015) suggest instead of focusing on the mathematical ideas in the problems as a whole, similarities and differences between problems and actual student approaches and thinking to the problems. Overall, the focus of homework should be to improve conceptual understanding, fluency, and flexibility in math. Math Homework Figure 13: Assign Meaningful Homework 1 4 Homework needs to be Focus on conceptual meaningful and understanding, purposeful (NCTM, n.d). reasoning, fluency, and flexibility Homework When taking up assignments should not be drill and 2 3 homework, do not go one problem at a time practice questions (Otten et al, 2015) (Swank, 1999) 20 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

Make Mathematics Fun Mathematics needs to be fun and engaging. According to Colgan (2014), a large majority of students find mathematics “boring, mostly irrelevant and unrewarding” (Colgan, 2014, p. 1). This need not be the case, however, as educators should strive to use resources and strategies that capture student interest and spike motivation (Colgan, 2014). Examples include use of: Educational apps (such as Kahoot!) Math games (such as Mathemagic or the Prime Radicals Game) (Colgan, 2014) TV programs/videos (such as the TVOkids program The Prime Radicals) (Colgan, 2014) Stories and books that incorporate mathematics (such as Mathemagic! Number Tricks) (Colgan, 2014) Use physical movements in the classroom to act the mathematics (Rittle-Johnson & Jordan, 2016) ‘Math busking’, using street performing to learn about math (Robertson Program for Inquiry-based Teaching in Mathematics and Science, 2016) Making Math Fun Figure 14: Making Mathematics Fun Math needs to be fun and engaging. Following are some recommendations on how to make math class more fun. 01 02 03 04 Include TV Read stories Incorporate Use programs or or books that math games educational videos with incorporate (Colgan, apps math math 2014) (Colgan, (Colgan, 2014) 2014) TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 21

Building Positive Attitudes in Mathematics Having a positive outlook in mathematics is an important factor in student achievement (Colgan, 2014). Several researchers have found a positive correlation between positive mathematics attitudes and mathematics achievement, demonstrating that students with a positive attitude about mathematics had greater success in mathematics (Mata, Monteiro, & Peixoto, 2012). Unfortunately, many students have negative attitudes towards mathematics and feel that they are not good at math (Colgan, 2014). In the most recent TIMMS study conducted in 2011, only 35% of students in Grade 4 and 32% of students in Grade 8 reported liking mathematics (EQAO, 2011). Several factors in the school environment including teacher support, student-to student interaction, and teacher expectations can affect attitudes in mathematics (Mata et al., 2012). Akey (2006) concluded that students have a better attitude towards mathematics when their teacher has a very positive attitude about mathematics (Mata et al., 2012). Additionally, teachers with a more positive attitude in mathematics are perceived to be better at supporting students (Mata et al., 2012). Furthermore, teachers who establish partnerships with parents/caregivers are better able to support students (TKCalifornia, 2016). Figure 15: Building Positive Attitudes in Mathematics Researchers have found a positive correlation between a positive attitude in math and success in math (Mata, Monteiro & Peixoto, 2012) Establish Teachers need to partnerships with project a very parents/caregivers to better support Building Positive positive attitude about math (Mata, students Attitudes in Math Monteiro & Peixoto, (TKCalifornia, 2016) 2012) Students need to feel supported by their teachers (TKCalifornia, 2016) 22 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies

Reduce Mathematics Anxiety Some students report anxiety or nervousness in mathematics, and as educators, we must be able to recognize that math anxiety is real, and be aware of strategies to reduce mathematics anxiety with our students (Stuart, 2000). Mathematics anxiety can be characterized by math avoidance, obsessing over everything that is not understood, or viewing math as a punishment (Stuart, 2000). Most often a lack of confidence in mathematical abilities can lead to anxiety in mathematics, but many other things can attribute to mathematics anxiety including teacher attitudes, peer attitudes, and family attitudes (Stuart, 2000). Ho et al. (2000) conducted a study with 671 students in Grade 6 in China, Taiwan, and the United States and found that math anxiety has an impact on student achievement. As such, teachers must be aware of teaching strategies to help reduce math anxiety. Jackson and Leffingwell (1999) conducted a study with 157 pre-service elementary school teachers on their personal experience with math anxiety in the classroom and based on their findings, the authors provided the following recommendations for teachers to help with math anxiety: Be aware of teacher impact on students Project a happy and positive attitude that you want to teach in each and every one in your classes Be encouraging. Do not make students feel embarrassed for asking for help Try to include student interests into the class Provide extra time or help for students who may suffer from math anxiety Give instructions both in written and verbal formats (Jackson & Leffingwell, 1999) Figure 16: Recommendations to Reduce Mathematics Anxiety Reduce Math Anxiety Some students report anxiety with mathematics, and following are some recommendations based on Jackson and Leffingwell (1999) to help with reducing math anxiety. Project a happy and Beware of teacher’s 01 impact on students positive 02 attitude in every class Incorporate student’s 03 Encourage students interest in class 04 Reducing Math Provide instruction in a 05 Avoid time constraints Anxiety variety of ways 06 TEACHING AND LEARNING MATHEMATICS RESEARCH SERIES I: Effective Instructional Strategies 23

You can also read